
Playa Largo Resort & Spa
Best for families and travelers who want a larger resort with multiple dining venues, an on-site spa, marina access and organized activities.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
Playa Largo Resort & Spa is a 14.5-acre family-friendly bayfront resort in Key Largo with multiple restaurants, a spa, marina access and a rare sandy beach—good for families and watersports-focused travelers. Amara Cay Resort is a stylish, 4-star beachfront resort in Islamorada that suits couples and active travelers who want direct beach access and easy access to local dive and fishing operators.
Updated · about 24 miles apart

Best for families and travelers who want a larger resort with multiple dining venues, an on-site spa, marina access and organized activities.

Best for travelers who prefer an Islamorada beachfront base with straightforward beach access and proximity to local dive/fishing operators.
When Playa Largo Resort & Spa wins: pick Playa Largo if you want a bigger property with several distinct restaurants and bars, an on-site full spa, marina/watersports options and family-oriented amenities (kids programs, children’s pool, activity programming).
When Amara Cay Resort wins: choose Amara Cay if you want a smaller, stylish beachfront stay in Islamorada with direct beach access, a simpler layout and proximity to local dive centers and fishing spots.
Bottom line: Playa Largo is the fuller-service, family-forward resort with more on-site facilities and event space; Amara Cay is a solid, well-rated Islamorada option for travelers who prioritize beachfront location and a compact, polished resort experience.
| Category | Playa Largo Resort & Spa | Amara Cay Resort |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Larger, family-oriented bayfront resort with multiple venues and activities | Stylish, compact beachfront resort focused on beach access and nearby watersports |
| Location | Key Largo, private bayfront on Florida Bay near John Pennekamp Coral Reef State Park | Islamorada (Matecumbe), on a private beachfront stretch close to local dive/fishing operators |
| Size / rooms | Approximately 177–178 rooms, suites, bungalows, villas and a beach house | 110 rooms |
| Ages / policy | All ages — family-friendly with kids programs and children’s amenities | All ages — not adults-only |
| Pools & beach | Year-round outdoor pool(s), private sandy bayfront beach, kids’ zero-entry pool area | Outdoor pool(s) and an on-site private beach |
| Restaurants & bars | Four venues listed (Sol by the Sea, La Marea, Las Olas ceviche bar, Sand Bar) | Two restaurants and multiple bars/lounges; room service during limited hours |
| Spa & wellness | Ocean Spa with treatments, oceanside massage pavilion and 24-hour fitness center | Fitness facilities on site; no full-service spa listed in supplier data |
| Watersports & activities | Marina watersports, snorkeling from shoreline, water-skiing, daily eco programming, bicycles | Kayaking, snorkeling and scuba diving on site; boat tours and fishing nearby |
| Event & meeting space | Extensive event venues including large beachfront and multiple ballrooms | Smaller property; supplier listing notes 1 meeting room |
| Known for | Private bayfront acreage with sandy beach and family programming | Beachfront Islamorada location and proximity to Bud n’ Mary’s Dive Center |
Playa Largo sits on 14.5 private bayfront acres in Key Largo with direct access to Florida Bay and easy drives to John Pennekamp Coral Reef State Park.
Pick Playa Largo for a larger bayfront property with marina access and easy entry to Key Largo’s reef activities.
Amara Cay is in Matecumbe (Islamorada) with a private beachfront location and close walking/driving access to local dive and fishing operators.
Choose Amara Cay for a straightforward Islamorada beachfront stay near dive and fishing activity hubs.
Playa Largo offers a wide range of room types—from standard rooms to multi-bedroom beach houses—suited to families and groups.
Playa Largo is better if you need larger or more varied accommodation options for families or groups.
Amara Cay lists 110 air-conditioned rooms and suites with a range of partial oceanview, oceanfront and courtyard options.
Amara Cay suits travelers after compact, ocean-facing rooms in a mid-size resort.
Playa Largo has four distinct on-property restaurants and bars spanning seafood, Mediterranean, ceviche and a casual sand-front bar.
More on-site variety at Playa Largo makes it easier to stay in for most meals, especially for families.
Amara Cay offers two restaurants and several bars/lounges plus limited room service hours.
Amara Cay provides straightforward beachfront dining with fewer on-site restaurant choices than Playa Largo.
Playa Largo features a year-round outdoor pool, private sandy bayfront beach, a kids’ zero-entry pool area and resort cabanas for rent.
Playa Largo is aimed at families and groups who want a variety of pool and beach experiences on-site.
Amara Cay has at least one outdoor pool and an on-site private beach for guest use.
Amara Cay gives you direct beachfront access with a simpler pool area suited to couples and active beachgoers.
Playa Largo includes Ocean Spa, a 24-hour fitness center and evening programming across its outdoor spaces.
If you want an on-site full spa plus varied night-time venues, Playa Largo is the stronger choice.
Amara Cay lists fitness facilities and several bars/lounges but no full spa in the supplier listing.
Amara Cay works if you prioritize beach days and nearby evening options in Islamorada rather than an on-site spa.

Playa Largo — more family-focused amenities, kids’ pool and wide range of room types including multi-bedroom beach houses.

Amara Cay — direct Islamorada beachfront location with quick access to local dive and fishing operators.

Playa Largo — four distinct restaurants and bars covering seafood, Mediterranean and a ceviche lounge.

Amara Cay — stylish, mid-size property with oceanfront suites and simpler, walkable layout.
Playa Largo is better for families—its materials and listings show kids’ programming, a children’s pool area and larger multi-bedroom options.
Amara Cay has very close access to local dive centers (Bud n’ Mary’s is within walking distance) and Islamorada’s fishing infrastructure; Playa Largo is closer to Key Largo dive and reef operators.
Not published: the supplier listing for Amara Cay mentions fitness facilities but does not list a full-service spa; Playa Largo’s Ocean Spa is published.
Yes. Both properties accept guests of all ages and are not adults-only.
Explore how Playa Largo Resort & Spa stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·