
Playa Largo Resort & Spa
Best for families and guests who want a larger resort with a dedicated spa, on-site marina access and private sandy shoreline.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
Playa Largo Resort & Spa is a large, family-friendly bayfront resort in Key Largo with private sand, an on-site spa, and multiple dining venues — read this if you want a family or multi-activity Keys base with marina access. Islander Resort is a long-running beachfront property in Islamorada with classic Keys rooms, two pools and several on-site restaurants — read this if you prefer a central Islamorada beach stay close to dining and attractions.
Updated · about 35 km apart (driving along US-1)

Best for families and guests who want a larger resort with a dedicated spa, on-site marina access and private sandy shoreline.

Best for travelers who want a well-known Islamorada beachfront hotel within walking distance of local restaurants, breweries and arts attractions.
When Playa Largo Resort & Spa wins: choose Playa Largo if you want a bigger property with a variety of room types (including multi-bedroom beach houses), a dedicated Ocean Spa, marina watersports access and resort programming geared to families and groups.
When Islander Resort wins: pick Islander if you want to stay in the heart of Islamorada with immediate beach access, multiple on-site restaurants and bars, two outdoor pools and easy walking access to local points of interest.
Bottom line: Playa Largo is the better option for families or guests focused on spa services, private bayfront beach and watersports from a marina; Islander is a stronger choice for travelers prioritizing an Islamorada beach location and a compact property with convenient on-site dining and meeting facilities.
| Category | Playa Largo Resort & Spa | Islander Resort |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Family- and activity-focused bayfront resort with spa and marina access | Classic beachfront hotel in central Islamorada with casual dining and bars |
| Location | Key Largo, near John Pennekamp Coral Reef State Park and marina (Overseas Hwy address) | Islamorada (Matecumbe) on Overseas Highway, steps from Lorelei Restaurant & Cabana Bar |
| Size (rooms) | 177–178 rooms, suites, bungalows, villas and a beach house | 114 guestrooms |
| Ages / policy | All-ages, family-friendly; kids programs and kids’ menus | All-ages, not adults-only |
| Pools | Year-round outdoor pool, private cabanas, kids pool / zero-entry kids area and 24-hour pool access for guests | Two outdoor pools, pool cabanas (surcharge) and poolside bar |
| Beach | Private bayfront sandy beach with chairs, hammocks and beach cabanas (surcharge) | Private beach / on private beach with beach bar and beach cabanas (surcharge) |
| Restaurants & bars | Four venues: Sol by the Sea, La Marea, Las Olas (ceviche bar) and Sand Bar (toes-in-the-sand) | Three on-site restaurants including Tides Beachside Bar, plus a beach bar and poolside bar |
| Spa & wellness | Ocean Spa on-site with massages, facials, open-air massage pavilion and salon services | Health/beauty spa listed as nearby (onsite spa details not published) |
| Meetings & events | Multiple indoor ballrooms and extensive outdoor/ beachfront event lawns (venues for large weddings and conferences) | Conference center with 13 meeting rooms and a ballroom — good for meetings and events |
| Family & activities | Kids club, free bicycles, watersports from marina, eco-programming and snorkeling on site | Free bicycles, water sports equipment on site, tours/ticket assistance and evening entertainment |
Playa Largo sits on 14.5 private bayfront acres in Key Largo, close to John Pennekamp Coral Reef State Park and a short drive to local snorkel and dive operators.
Choose Playa Largo for quieter bayfront access and easy boat-based activities in Key Largo.
Islander Resort sits in central Islamorada (Matecumbe) on the Overseas Highway, within walking distance of local restaurants, the Keys History & Discovery Center and breweries.
Pick Islander for a convenient Islamorada location close to restaurants and small local attractions.
Playa Largo offers a broad set of room types — rooms, suites, bungalows, villas and 3-bedroom beach houses for families or groups.
If you need larger family or multi-room accommodation, Playa Largo’s selection is the stronger fit.
Islander has a wide variety of room and bungalow options—from Tropical View rooms to oceanfront junior suites and multiple accessible room types.
Islander is a flexible choice for travelers wanting traditional Keys-style rooms and some bungalow options with ocean views.
Playa Largo runs four distinct venues covering seafood, Mediterranean, ceviche and a casual sand-side bar.
Playa Largo is a solid choice if you want on-site variety and waterside dining without leaving the property.
Islander has three restaurants including a beachside option (Tides Beachside Bar) plus multiple bars for pool or beach drinks.
Islander is convenient if you want hotel beach dining plus quick access to Islamorada’s local restaurant scene.
Playa Largo’s shoreline is bayfront with a rare sandy beach for Key Largo, plus a year-round pool and kids’ water features.
Playa Largo is preferable for guests who want sand-on-your-feet beach time plus marina-based watersports.
Islander offers two outdoor pools and direct beach access with a beach bar and beach cabanas available for surcharge.
Islander delivers the straightforward beachfront hotel experience in Islamorada with multiple pools and beach options.
Playa Largo has Ocean Spa, an included 24-hour fitness center (via destination fee) and nightly outdoor events.
Choose Playa Largo if on-site spa treatments and organized wellness programming matter to you.
Islander lists a health/beauty spa nearby and offers evening entertainment plus poolside and beach bars.
Islander works well for guests who want simpler on-site nightlife and easy access to Islamorada bars and music.

Playa Largo: wider room mix (including 3‑bedroom Beach Houses), kids programming and family-oriented amenities.

Islander: central Islamorada location within walking distance of restaurants, breweries and the arts district.

Playa Largo: Ocean Spa with massages, facials and an oceanside massage pavilion.

Islander: on-site conference center and 13 meeting rooms make it convenient for meetings and small events.
Playa Largo is the clearer family pick: kids’ menus, kids’ camp/activities, a zero-entry kids pool area and family-sized accommodation options.
Islander is within walking distance of several Islamorada restaurants and attractions; Playa Largo has multiple on-site venues but is more spread out on a private bayfront parcel.
No. Both properties welcome guests of all ages; neither is an adults-only resort.
Playa Largo has marina access and is closer to John Pennekamp Coral Reef State Park for snorkel and dive trips; Islander offers water-sport equipment on site and nearby dive/tour options in Islamorada.
Explore how Playa Largo Resort & Spa stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·