
Playa Largo Resort & Spa
Best for families and travelers who want a full-service, bayfront resort with multiple dining options, an on-site spa, and a wider range of room types (rooms, suites, villas, beach house).
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
Playa Largo Resort & Spa is a larger, family-focused bayfront resort in Key Largo with multiple restaurants, an on-site spa, and a private sandy beach—good for families and travelers who want resort amenities and waterfront activities. Fisher Inn Resort & Marina is a smaller Islamorada waterfront resort and marina with an outdoor pool, dock access and complimentary on-the-go breakfast—best for travelers wanting a recognizable Upper Keys marina property on a modest budget.
Updated

Best for families and travelers who want a full-service, bayfront resort with multiple dining options, an on-site spa, and a wider range of room types (rooms, suites, villas, beach house).

Best for travelers seeking a straightforward waterfront motel-style stay with marina access, on-site boat facilities and a smaller-property feel in Islamorada.
When Playa Largo Resort & Spa wins: choose Playa Largo if you want a full resort experience—private sandy beach, multiple restaurants and bars (Sol by the Sea, La Marea, Las Olas, Sand Bar), a staffed Ocean Spa, more room types including villas and a beach house, and family-oriented programming.
When Fisher Inn Resort & Marina wins: pick Fisher Inn if you want a lower-key Islamorada waterfront base with direct marina/dock access, a simple beachfront vibe, fewer rooms (22 individually decorated guestrooms) and a complimentary on-the-go breakfast.
Bottom line: Playa Largo is a full-service resort for families and guests who prioritize on-site dining, spa and larger property amenities; Fisher Inn is a smaller, more budget-conscious waterfront choice for visitors focused on marina access and a compact, hands-on stay.
| Category | Playa Largo Resort & Spa | Fisher Inn Resort & Marina |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Resort-scale, family-focused, multiple venues and programmed activities | Small waterfront motel/resort with marina and on-site boating focus |
| Location | Key Largo, private bayfront setting near John Pennekamp Coral Reef State Park | Islamorada, waterfront with dock and walkable access to local attractions |
| Size (rooms) | About 177–178 rooms, suites, bungalows, villas and a beach house | 22 individually decorated guestrooms |
| Ages / policy | All ages; family amenities and kids programming (kids' menu, kids club) | |
| Pools / beach | Year-round outdoor pool, private sandy beach, kids' pool, 24-hour pool access for guests | Outdoor pool and private beach access; pool hours published 7:00 AM–7:00 PM |
| Restaurants & bars | Four on-site venues: Sol by the Sea, La Marea, Las Olas, Sand Bar | Not published |
| Spa & wellness | Ocean Spa with massages, facials, oceanside massage pavilion; 24-hour fitness center (included in destination fee) | Not published |
| Watersports & marina | Private marina, watersports, snorkeling on-site, fishing poles included in destination fee | Dock, boat and paddles on site, fishing on site, motor boating, nearby boat tours |
| Breakfast & extras | Breakfast available on-site for a fee; daily destination fee covers a welcome beverage and other perks | Complimentary on-the-go breakfast served daily 8:00 AM–10:30 AM |
| Parking | Self-parking and valet available (fees apply) | Free self parking onsite |
Playa Largo sits on 14.5 private bayfront acres in Key Largo on Overseas Highway with close access to John Pennekamp Coral Reef State Park.
Choose Playa Largo for a larger bayfront resort with direct access to Key Largo marine attractions.
Fisher Inn Resort & Marina is located on Overseas Hwy in Islamorada with dock access and short walks to local points of interest.
Pick Fisher Inn for a compact Islamorada base with quick marina access and local walkability.
Playa Largo offers a broad mix of rooms, suites, bungalows, villas and a multi-bedroom beach house across a large property.
Playa Largo gives more variety and larger units suited to families or groups.
Fisher Inn has 22 individually decorated guestrooms with a selection of balcony and oceanfront suites.
Fisher Inn is a smaller set of room types focused on straightforward waterfront lodging.
Playa Largo operates four distinct on-site venues covering seafood, Mediterranean plates, a ceviche bar and a casual beach bar.
Playa Largo is for guests who want several on-site dining styles without leaving the resort.
Fisher Inn’s supplier listing does not publish in-house restaurant names or a broad dining program.
Fisher Inn suits guests who plan to eat off-property or use simple in-room facilities; on-site full-service restaurants are not published.
Playa Largo’s signature amenities center on its private sandy beach, year-round pool(s) and family water programming.
Playa Largo is aimed at guests who want both beach and pool options plus on-site watersports.
Fisher Inn highlights its dock and marina services alongside a single outdoor pool and beachfront access.
Fisher Inn is best for guests prioritizing marina access and boating rather than a broad resort beach program.
Playa Largo includes a full-service Ocean Spa and a 24-hour fitness center; evening options include waterfront bars and casual nightlife.
Playa Largo supports a fuller wellness and low-key on-property evening program.
Fisher Inn’s listing emphasizes outdoor recreation and marina activities rather than a dedicated spa or fitness center.
Fisher Inn focuses on waterside leisure; for spa and fitness, guests typically visit off-property or elsewhere.

Playa Largo — multiple family-friendly room types, kids' programming, private sandy beach and family pool options.

Fisher Inn — dock and marina facilities, boat on site and fish cleaning table make it a practical base for anglers and boaters.

Playa Largo — four distinct restaurants and bars covering seafood, Mediterranean fare, ceviche and a beach bar.

Fisher Inn — smaller property with complimentary breakfast and free self parking for a simpler, lower-cost waterfront option.
Playa Largo — it’s explicitly family-focused with kids’ menus, kids' club programming, a children's pool and larger multi-bedroom units.
Fisher Inn is focused on marina and dock access and includes boat-related features; Playa Largo also offers marina/watersports but is a larger resort with broader programming.
Fisher Inn provides a complimentary on-the-go breakfast daily; Playa Largo offers breakfast on-site for an additional fee (not included in room rates).
Playa Largo has a full Ocean Spa with a range of treatments and an oceanside massage pavilion; Fisher Inn’s listing does not publish an on-site spa.
Explore how Playa Largo Resort & Spa stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·